In the spirit of the profusion of “Apologies to Women” that sprung up on Facebook a while back, I thought that as a species, we women were remiss in offering a response. Poor guys, taking the brunt for all of it! No way! Here you go guys, a response. May all sentient beings now have very good sex.

It is with deep regret and sadness that I write this letter.  It is to every man that I have ever dated (or something of that nature) and I want to say the most difficult words that will likely ever cross my lips:  I apologize.

I apologize for the fact that I did not do the work to recognize that – despite whatever delusions I desperately indulged in – there is no way around it: nothing but everything from you will do.  I know I told you it would be alright if you bought me another pair of shoes, or if we spent the next seven hours processing.  I know that I made subtle promises that you didn’t have to do anything but be there, hang out and let me love you, or that once we “settled down” I would be happy.  I lied.

I apologize that I was unwilling to answer this question of what women want, leaving you frustrated and confused.  I left it open-ended and murky because I thought you would say no.  I want you, all of you, wide awake and ready to play.  I want you to handle me,  so that I can stop “taking care” of everything.  I want you to tell me to stop, just stop, lie down – and to know that you are totally capable of taking over.  I won’t believe it at first (and at second and at third).  I won’t believe it until you show me repeatedly.  I want you to be willing to subdue my doubt with your conviction.

I apologize for all the smokescreens I put up, trying to cover my one simple yes-or-no question: do you want to go deep, throw all of our chips in the pot and see what we come up with, or not?  I let my fear drive: fear that you’re a guy and as such, scared of commitment – not the commitment of marriage but the commitment of soul – to go all the way to see what you, what I, what we, are made of.  (Yes, I know how to push your buttons, how to activate that fear, and then be like, “Who me?”)  I am here waiting for you to commit, that is all.  I didn’t say that I am just as scared as you even though it looks like I am the one who is pushing for it.

I apologize that I did not ask the difficult questions at the beginning.  That I was essentially a drug dealer and hoped to get you so hooked that you had no way out. Rather than just asking you if you wanted to go deep, if that turned you on, if you were prepared.  I hoped that we could deal with that issue when we came to it.  Invariably when it did, when the bill came, you felt duped and upset.  Rightly so.

I apologize for the times when I used my sex as a bargaining chip – to get you to love me, to want me, to claim me.  And then, when I had you and no longer needed to bargain, stopped having sex.  I apologize for seeing you as a security conquest, giving you the best sex of your life right before you gave me the commitment.

I apologize for the big fat lie I intimated, that I was a “finite game,” and that after you completed the following tasks we would now return you to your regularly-scheduled programming – that you could return to the peace and comfort of your mind, and I would leave you alone in the sanctuary, away from my chaos and unpredictability.  I am sorry that I did not say, I want all of you and I want you to have all of me, and if we are going to be in a relationship of that nature, it will require never-ending engagement on both of our parts – it’s not a one-time shot.  We don’t win each other and then check that one off the list, moving on to more productive things.  The getting each other is not the end but the beginning of the game.  And that game never stops.  I misrepresented myself as “easy.”  (The free razor-blade handle.)  My confession is that I am anything but easy and get more, not less, challenging.  This is not the bunny slope.  Beware.

And I apologize for playing “nice” – because as a woman, the only way I am going to be nice is to shut down the rest of me. I was not clear with you that I am like a game of obstacles, and you get the temporary respite that is nice under two circumstances: when I give up on you, or when you figure out the Rubic’s cube and handle me.  My kindness is the most cruel thing I can do to you, because without challenge you become a mediocre man.

I apologize for believing that my only power with you was withholding and withdrawal.  For believing you too weak and fragile to withstand my power and wrath.  For walking on eggshells with you, careful never to bruise your ego, lest you leave me for “an easier woman.”  I will tell you that at the root of quiet kindness is a rage of everything I believe I cannot tell you.  And that where it has come down to the options of either fuck-or-fight breakthrough, or the learned-helplessness that results from kindness, all too often I have chosen the latter.  I have not had the courage to be a great woman, the kind of woman who can make you a king, only a good woman who will “support” you, not the queen who would compel you, propel you, forge you.

Yes, I apologize for not admitting that I am the one who holds the power and you the authority to carry out the laws.  I apologize that I did not learn to hold or wield this power in such a way that the benefit of serving it was obvious.  I apologize that I did not recognize that this power was rooted in my sexuality – that I left you there holding the sex piece on behalf of both of us, and then was victimized when you reached for me.  I did not hold up my side of the sexual bargain in terms of holding that much hunger and desire, projecting it all onto you.  We both lost in this equation.  Because I want nothing more than for you to be inside of me, but admitting that, fully owning it, means that I have to accept the full responsibility of citizenship in womanhood rather than girlhood.  And it often looks like I lose a lot of the perks like being cute and sweet and easy.

And I apologize for the fact that I sold both of us out, that when I hit that state of H.A.L.T. – hungry, angry, lonely, and tired – I lost faith in you and settled for food, arguments, fucking, and crawling under the covers and hiding out, rather than trusting that you were capable of offering nourishment, power, the kind of sex where I lose track of who I am, and waking up.  There IS no excuse.

I apologize most of all for ever believing that I could be that woman and then trying to sell you that big fat lie.  I tried, I donned as many mental and emotional corsets as I could.  I tried to smile and laugh and be easygoing, like a 70’s song where you would see me walking on the beach in a white dress with long straight brown natural hair, tossed by a breeze.  Or changing a baby’s diaper, glancing over at you, so proud that you could be my baby’s daddy.  I even tried to be sad and sick so that you could feel strong and protective, so that you could feel like society’s definition of a man.  The only problem is that I don’t want that man.  (And I am sick of all the ace bandages and Kleenex boxes.)

I tried also to be good prey, to hold back my secrets, my desire, my passion and hunger, my unbearable hunger for sex so that you could chase me and I could squeal and you could pound your chest and come and get it.  I just can’t help it, my desire is unruly and wily and untamed, and I see when that part of me comes out how you think I am a madwoman, a little scary, and how you don’t quite know what to do with yourself, and you start perusing good housekeeping the way that a man who hasn’t encountered one so feral and had the shit scared out of him looks at hardcore porn, just to get a taste of what it would be like to be normal again.

I am sorry that I settled for love without passion.

I am sorry for all the times I let you off the hook – you know, like when you got scared and didn’t call.  Or when you didn’t know what to do with me and shuffled into the other room onto the sanctuary of the computer, or into your office into the sanctuary of another woman. When that happened I fell under the same tyranny of fear that held you, and I was not willing to trust that you could actually hear the truth, that it hurt, that it sucked, that I missed you, that I love you.  I believed that you were actually incapable of showing up.  And in that I made you less of a man.

I apologize for going out with you when I knew that I was way out of your league, but happened to be lonely and bored… and then pumped you up, boosted you up and then fell in love with my own creation – only to discover that when I pulled the plug on all the juice I pumped in, you deflated back to who you always were, feeling resentful and confused that I was no longer interested, and that you no longer were getting your free fix.

And I deeply apologize for translating feminine language for you.  I know it’s like cuneiform or something, but in translating it for you, I treated you the way an American is treated in France when everyone writes you off immediately as a stupid American and coddle you by speaking in English.  And a year later you still haven’t learned the language, you remain a foreigner.  I bought the story that you told me that you were dumb and simple and don’t get it.  That is how my superiority manifested itself.  And it isn’t fair to you.

I apologize for not saying to you, please-please-please stop with the “divine goddess” schtick, and the sensitivity, and meeting me with the perfect complement of “deep masculinity” – if I wanted that man I would find him.  I want you in all of your weird, quirky, imperfect, totally unpolished self. That is where I fall in love with you.  I am sorry that I was so unwilling to give you any fucking clue about how to be with me that you had to listen to other men who are equally clueless, and turn into a caricature of yourself.

Lastly, I apologize for trying to protect you from feeling how much, how deeply I love you.  How deeply cannot be fathomed.

 

« »